The American Hotel
The American Hotel
Built in 1846, at the height of the whaling era, this boutique hotel has stayed true to its historic roots. Oil paintings and antique furnishings make guests feel as if they’ve taken a step back in time. 49 Main St., 725-3535; theamericanhotel.com
Baron’s Cove Inn
The lush grounds provide a picturesque setting for this sprawling hotel, which offers a sparkling pool, tennis court and spacious rooms. 31 W. Water St., 725-2100; baronscove.com
Harborwoods Guesthouse
Owned by a Swedish transplant, this bed and breakfast offers a gourmet breakfast on the expansive porch. With only four guestrooms, the atmosphere is intimate and welcoming. 1702 Sag Harbor Turnpike, 537-6393; harborwoodsguesthouse.com
Sag Harbor Inn
Each of the 42 rooms has a private terrace or balcony overlooking the harbor. The Inn is nicely situated near the heart of town. 45 W. Water St., 725-2949; sagharborinn.com
